You are right about the AP getting started. There was such a mess with what was AWGS and Jerry asked me on an email if I knew anything about starting a forum. I didn't but knew Newt a bit as he had emailed me a few times when he saw I was from Grand Rapids. He had lived on the northwest side of GR and emailed a few comments along the way. So then I sent his name to Jerry to pick Newt's brains. In the meantime, Zac had been causing fits at AWGS. He was a kid who seemed to stir the water with whatever he said. He told he was a Christian so Mikey and I both tried to mentor him a bit. In talking with him on emails, I learned he was into computer big time and had set up webpages and forums before. So I told Jerry maybe Zac could set up a forum if that is where he was going with the idea. So Jerry contacted him and contracted with him to set up AP. Sean was a member of the other forum. But right away, Zac got lippy with people and I told Jerry he should do whatever he felt, so he changed the password and told Zac to take a hike. Then he asked Sean to be the techy and he has ever since. But I'm sure they agreed that what was needed was close supervision of the forum. I think you have it nailed to some extent about those two. Jerry hates to have to discipline people but will if he has to. Whereas I think Sean is a bit into power. What do that call that----passive/aggressive. But still, if he didn't think the story should have been being posted, he should have said so from the beginning. As for them being Nazis, UM, welll not exactly but suspect Jerry didn't feel it was worth going to bat against Sean and losing his techy. After all Sean doesn't get paid and spends lots of time keeping the forum going. Jerry can't do it as he doesn't have the knowledge. So if it was a matter of keeping you two OR Sean, you were bound to lose.
Even though Sean said some pretty nasty stuff to me that wasn't true at all, right in public on the forum, I didn't return my answer in the same way. I PMed it to him. Whether he got the message or read it, I'll never know because he never replied. Blindtoo and another told him off and I received several PMs and emails wondering where Sean was coming from, doing what he did. And that was enough for me. As long as everyone else saw me in a different light, it was OK. I could overlook Sean. The nasty post was removed in a couple of hours.
But JW and BF, I don't really know what was behind the banning. I still think it was a knee jerk reaction and once it was done, he wasn't about to lose face and back down.
AS for J, what I heard was that Jerry had said something negative on a post and Joyce thought he was talking about her. When she said something to him about it, of course he told her that wasn't so, but she didn't believe him. That was before your banning and Sean's nastiness to me. Yes, I have talked about J on PMs when people asked me about her. I never said anything that wasn't true and the things I said were always coupled with the good I saw in her. She was a great artist, she was a good mom, she was extremely knowledgeable about plants, she was a very giving person and sympathetic. There was just one or two things that ruined the picture. She couldn't stand anybody crossing her or couldn't stand if somebody said something that she THOUGHT they were putting her down. Also couldn't stand anybody mentioning God or their faith. She by the way was not the only pagan on that forum.